竞品分析六步法沉淀人审页

有道云竞品分析六步法沉淀与智慧食堂竞品分析报告

Date: 2026-06-28
User request: 调用有道云 CLI 获取《# 产品人必看：竞品分析流程全解析》，把文章思路保存到本项目，并按该思路生成智慧食堂竞品分析报告。
Task id: ZHCTPROMPT-20260628-COMPETITIVE-ANALYSIS-FLOW
Evidence level: C for article method; B/C/D for project smart-canteen materials.

Source Verification

youdaonote check --json passed. youdaonote search '产品人必看竞品分析流程全解析' precisely found note id DAAC1C29276C43F5AE846C801CAA53D8. youdaonote read DAAC1C29276C43F5AE846C801CAA53D8 was executed.

The note content is image-first WeChat material. The original bad-title note 050B8492A3A54847AD7D874EA3C1C701 only contained residual WeChat UI text. I downloaded article images to /tmp only for review, converted WebP to PNG locally, and manually verified the readable method diagrams. Raw images and full OCR text are not committed.

Method Extracted

The article provides a practical competitor-analysis workflow:

Clarify goals: decision support, learning benchmark, market warning.
Select competitors: direct, indirect, substitute.
Choose dimensions: product perspective and user perspective.
Collect information: financial reports, industry media, data sites.
Organize and analyze: comparison, matrix, functional decomposition, demand exploration, PEST, SWOT, five forces.
Summarize report: competition strategy, product suggestions, and action plan.

It also proposes a report template: cover, analysis background, competitor selection, key findings, dimension analysis, conclusion, and appendix.

Outputs

Output	Path
Source index	`work/2026-06-28-competitive-analysis-flow-smart-canteen-report/source-index.csv`
Stable method page	`standards-stack/llm-wiki/product-methods/competitive-analysis-six-step-flow.md`
Workflow	`standards-stack/prompt/governance/COMPETITIVE_ANALYSIS_DECISION_WORKFLOW.md`
Smart-canteen report Markdown	`work/2026-06-28-competitive-analysis-flow-smart-canteen-report/smart-canteen-competitive-analysis-report.md`
Smart-canteen report HTML	`work/2026-06-28-competitive-analysis-flow-smart-canteen-report/smart-canteen-competitive-analysis-report.html`
Competitor matrix	`work/2026-06-28-competitive-analysis-flow-smart-canteen-report/competitor-matrix.csv`
Next research queue	`work/2026-06-28-competitive-analysis-flow-smart-canteen-report/next-research-queue.csv`
Method review HTML	`work/2026-06-28-competitive-analysis-flow-smart-canteen-report/competitive-analysis-flow-method-review.html`
Thread record	`work/team-learning/thread-records/2026-06-28/competitive-analysis-flow-smart-canteen-report.md`

Boundary

This is not an external market ranking. Most competitor claims are C/D until each company has a source-level public material, customer case, bid document, or system screenshot. Smart-canteen strategy conclusions remain draft where margin, cash collection, channel conversion, hardware cost, and competitor pricing are missing.

Validation

python3 control/scripts/task_index.py build: passed, rebuilt control/task-index/tasks.tsv from 267 item files.
python3 control/scripts/task_index.py validate: passed, validated 267 task rows.
git diff --check: passed.
CSV parse check: passed for source index, competitor matrix, next research queue, and the product-manager competitive-analysis source index.